post dated: 2.3.08
"to take an option for the poor does not mean to direct oneself toward one part of the whole in order to ignore the rest, but rather to direct oneself toward the whole from the standpoint of one part." (jon sobrino)
what follows are some thoughts and reflections on a trip i took with several students through downtown san jose to explore and gain exposure to the larger context and reality of homelessness in our city. before i begin, however, i think it's worthwhile to posit a few questions that examine our attitudes and assumptions about this broad issue.
first, let us consider popular slogans: "end homelessness!" do you think homelessness can be ended? and, if so, how long will it take? five, ten, fifty years? secondly, let me briefly say a few words on the disagreement of statistics. statistics are often thrown around in conversation and discussion to create stronger arguments, but when statistics are not in accord we have to wonder why it might be hard to gather precise numbers on such a nebulous population. further, is it more common to underestimate or overestimate numbers of homeless people? the united states government claims it provides 1/6 of the services for homeless people. where do you think the responsibility should fall for providing food and shelter to those in need? where is the balance between taxed citizens and government-funded social services? finally, why do you think the national coalition for the homeless, for example, chooses to focus on children and families in their educational materials? i think there's a misconception that intact families produce well-adjusted individuals and supportive communities.
one more common american perception and ideology: attitudinally, we believe in "the survival of the fittest" ethos. but how is this consistent with the teachings of spiritual leaders like jesus, for example, or gandhi? how does "survival of the fittest" acknowledge the presence and dignity of the least of our society?
pastor scott wagers, of c.h.a.m. ministry, threw several startling statistics on our final morning of the plunge. santa clara county, he says, has 7200 homeless people out of a population of 1,731,281 (2006 estimate), and the city of san jose--with a population of 974,000--claims to have 5500 homeless. nationwide there are as many as 35 million people living below the poverty line. you can check the national census bureau's most recent calcuations to learn more about the government's standard on poverty thresholds. scott wagers continued, there are at least one million homeless nationwide on any single night... and still we spend $7 billion each week in our war with iraq.
government-funded "h.u.d." (housing urban development) over 5 years from 1983 to 1988 cut it's budget from $83 billion to $18 billion each year... and it's no coincidence that in 1983 more americans saw more homeless roaming the streets, especially in larger cities like new york, chicago and los angeles. citizens have to wonder if poverty is a government policy. reagen, over the course of his 2 terms in office, systematically shifted government aide and funding from human services to industries (i.e. structural forces). the outcome of this economic growth became known as "reaganomics."
so, back to a few more domestic issues... there's a memorial that had recently been dedicated to the deceased homeless of san jose. what is the city saying when this memorial is placed in a courtyard of shelter that only homeless people see?
pastor scott wagers believes the solution to homelessness comes through organic organization by and for those in poverty. i agree that homelessness is an extension of poverty (again, is this an intentional government policy?), and though we must be careful not to confuse the two we must equally be determined to see the correlation. homelessness, likewise, must be understood in it's myriad forms: chronic, transitional, and episodic.
this weekend get-a-way throughout san jose exposed the many issues surrounding poverty and homelessness. i can't help but to continue to ask this final question: how do i understand my struggle for equality and an end to poverty when i am standing at the top oa an economic pyramid looking down all of those who support me?
8.11.2008
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)