3.12.2009

What I Learned in ED 451...

This blog posting takes on quite a different nature, as I'm usually waxing melodramatic on some aspect of nature and/or travel. In this case, however, I'm posting what I hope to be a panoramic spread of the terrain I've traversed in a recent course I've taken at Santa Clara University. The course, Technology in the Classroom, provided an array of technological tools to assist educators in navigating the uneven landscape of teaching. The class engaged essential questions, hopefully helping to orient our paradigms and pre-conceived notions of what's possible in technologically-based curriculum.

"What is meaningful learning, and how can technology serve as a tool in this process?" was a major theme throughout the quarter. With that in mind, I'd like to begin addressing this final portfolio; discussing, first, my reasons for this presentation and, secondly, specifically addressing insights I've gained as a learner from our class projects, as well as reflecting on where these projects might be relevant in the classroom.

Ed 451 introduced a multitude of different software programs and website-based projects like Garage Band and iMovie to WebQuest and iEarn, respectively. I found the rare theoretical conversations holding my attention more so than simple application, because I 
think another basic premise of a course like benefits from discussing advantages and disadvantages of using technology in the classroom. Pedagogically, I think teachers have used technology more as an end rather than a means. Technology, in this way, should be viewed as a tool and not the final product. In this way, technology can serve as a powerful means for student's situated cognition argued by Brown, Collins and Duguid. What's more, Eisner states that more forms of presentation offered to students the more intelligences are created. That is, experiences of this world that can be quantified in mathematics by use of formulae cannot be similarly expressed by poetry. What is conveyed in music is necessarily different than what is learned and expressed in painting. Different mediums of expression, including technology, present different forms of representation.

  1. Why do I express through this blog? Simply, it is a form of presentation I'm comfortable using: adding pictures, videos, and hyperlinks are a facile task. I think, too, it becomes an fluid forum where others can "follow" this blog, make comments to particular postings, and learn via the internet particular interests of the person posting. You, the reader, have a unique access to the world, presented by the world wide webs, as I see it... this is my digital thoughtprint. I think blogging is a fascinating phenomenon that has developed over the past 6 years, challenging the great Editorialists of, say, the NYTimes because now anyone can have an opinion. The flip-side, as with most content presented on the web, is there's a lot of good and bad content to sift through. It can be a bit unwieldy for the first time user. I think the implications for the classroom abound... that is, I'd love to see each of my students (in a continuing project) log their particular experiences and reflections of each of the world religions--a course I teach. As we move through different units I make available various projects that engage subtleties of the world's faith traditions not easily abstracted within a four-walled classroom. Establishing an individual blog would be a great way to check their progress. And, from an environmental perspective, it would be a unique way of reading their reflections without having to collect notebooks.
  2. Inspiration-8 offered our class the opportunity to work in pairs to diagram three readings we had read for class. This is a piece of software similar to Mind Map that I've used before, but the results of working with someone else dictated an entirely different process and, therefore, outcome. I tend to think in linear fashion, and working with Rohan forced me to reconsider this traditional approach for the alternative of throwing many thought-bubbles on the computer screen only to organize them afterward. I thought our findings were particularly more insightful and inter-connected than I might've been able to produce on my own. This type of a tool, granted the school can offer the software (or freeware), is a boon for students that different from me, think in abstract ways. Where I find myself referring often to outline-formats, Inspiration-8 allows the user to consider any and every idea that comes to mind while translating that to text as quickly as possible. After thoughts are with arrows, a click of a button will convert the entire cognitive map into a structured outline. It's an incredible tool for mapping curriculum, designing a course or lesson plan, writing a paper or think through a project. As with a lot technology, the only limit is the users creativity. This software, however, did not seem to be as "intuitive" as software we used later in the course.
  3. iEarn.org is a website based on "interactive curriculum-based projects in which students aged are creating, researching, sharing opinions, and becoming global citizens." It's a fascinating idea that students from around the world can create and contribute on projects. Working with Blanca, we were interested in connecting her work with adult learners and my work with high school students by having a collaborative project whereby adults ESL students write their cultural folktale (for example, a storie of origin) and adolescent students receiving the tale act it out. The goal, here, are many: it follows writing standards for adults, inter-personal skills for both groups, while students help ESL students generate the appropriate vocabulary for a good retelling of the story. Emotionally, students develop empathy for divergent perspectives and adults have a new sense of accomplishment. It's an interesting interactive site that throws the doors wide open on global learning, getting students of any age out of the confines of the classroom walls.
  4. The internet contains a lot of good and bad material, as mentioned before, and even the savviest user can easily lose perspective in there search for pertinent material. Especially in the case of students learning a new topic or subject, how could they more easily engage in self-guided web-based learning without falling into the perilous traps spread across all the web? Enter Trackstar. It's a desinged WebQuest tool to assist self-guided studies, whereby educators create "tracks" with corresponding questions, and as students navigate these tracks and answer the questions they form their own opinion on the matter. Now, in all fairness, these "tracks" still bear the digital thoughtprint of the teacher, and I think it's important that bias is understood. But the larger idea here is teaching students what is good versus bad material, and (more so) having them learn for themself and form their own opinions. Trackstar does this extremely well, and--while the interface is a bit a clumsy--I have found great success already with my students and the "tracks" I've created. I offer this as extra-credit opportunities for students incapable of getting away from home for a visit to a Buddhist retreat center or a Karmic lunch in Berkeley. Now, they are able to log on and engage each of the world religions, answering questions for each site I choose, and informing their own points of views. They've thouroughly enjoyed the option.
  5. The last web-based project we worked on was a class Wiki page. This is perhaps the one piece of technology I have the least experience with and, even after class discussions and course readings, I'm still unsure of the potential it holds for my work. Our professor asked us to contribute to the course Wiki by providing a link and abstract to "a good resource." As in most of our class assingments, there was little specification on what type of resource it should be so my initial thoughts were to provide information on my favorite music site. This didn't seem to offer much implications for my teaching and classroom work, so I reconsidered and chose the BBC's resource on world religions. You'll notice BBC’s website on religions opens with a section on a "featured religion," sidebars with related links and tools; this site contains a comprehensive listing of the world’s major faiths. I think in easier ways than blogging, Wiki pages are great ways for students to add and edit content on a particular topic. If, for instance, a student posted their blog on Mahayana Buddhist sects there would be little interaction and engagement by all the students in this project, other than what they individually--or if in small groups-learned by sharing their results. Adding, however, their search results to an ongoing Wiki-list creates more opportunities for students to see the changes made by others and check the verocity of those changes. It creates, I think, more astute learners who are once again in charge of their education.
  6. A project I really enjoyed working on and wish I had more time in class to perfect was a Google Earth Tour. It's really as simple as it sounds: we created stops around the globe for our virtual tour that bears upon a particular theme. My tour of India included notable stops from my most recent trip last summer, allowing the viewer to see: Varanasi, where many cremations are performed each day; Sarnath, where Buddha gave his first sermon on the four noble truths; and, Mt. Everst in the Himalaya, where the viewer see the headwaters of the Ganges River as well as learning the folklore behind this sacred river. For each stop you can post annotation, pictures and hyperlinks, making the tour as interactive as you wish. I would love to begin to offer this in any of my classes. My world religion students could pick up where they left off with Trackstar, learning about a particular religion, and make a global tour with Google Earth of what they learned. Freshman, learning Hebrew Scriptures, could offer tours of Abraham's journey to Canaan, or Moses leading the Israelites through the Sinai Peninsula.
  7. In a similar veing to Google Earth, I created a project for my freshmen studying the Isrealite Kings (i.e. Saul, David, and Solomon), and instructed them to re-create the Temple of Solomon using Google Sketchup. Over the course of the week, I assinged various tasks like making a cube, cylindrical columns, and so on. Over the weekend they had to apply these mini tasks towards making a temple based on the architectural measurments offered in the Bible. The results, naturally, were varied but fantastic nonetheless. The students said they learned a lot and enjoyed working with the new software saying, "it was fun and easy to use." They learned on their own to import images and textures for the walls and roof. Department colleagues as well have been impressed with the results hanging on my walls, and are now considering a similar project of their own.
  8. A feature of this course included weekely postings to the prompts. There's two postings I'd like to comment on including "how we'd implement podcasts", and "Given the reality of schools today, why will you bother to argue for change?"
  • Regarding the first prompt, the most meaningful portion remains on topic of social interaction and networking with tools like Facebook and YouTube. "Already, "YouTube" and "Facebook" allow students... to post video clips. Often, students will use these sites to post project videos they did for class. Podcasting allows these student groups to take a couple steps... towards the editing table, syncing voice-overs and soundtracks, and experimenting with other simple editing features. The group interaction creates a collaborative opportunity, and allows for more student participation."
  • As for the second, Matt Young, responding to my response--whereby education should foster opportunities for change in order to challenge the status quo of passive learning environments--said, "You mention Ford and the assembly line and I'm reminded of the division of labor that Ford didn't 'invent' but certainly utilized to great advantage. And the educational process itself seems to bear certain similarities: we divide knowledge up into 'subjects' and divide subjects up into 'classes' and divide classes up into a bunch of students toiling away on their own individual task. And this line of thinking leads me to - who else - Karl Marx and the idea that this process 'alientates the worker from the product of his labor.' The worker/student feels no real connection to the product/subject because his relation to it has been so 'divided.' And of course this leads me to the idea that the 'paradigm' shift you class for is just a bit like a call for revolution, a seizing of the means of production - that's what a lot of this class so far has been centered around, hasn't it? - a program in fostering 'class(room) consciousness' and the ushering in of a new age..." It's striking, and meaningful in terms of our educational system and speaks loudly about the importance of sites like Edutopia and Education in 21st century.
The last, and perhaps most intensive, projects we worked on involved using Apple's Garage Band and iMovie to create a seperate Podcast and Movie, respectively. For the last half of this ePortfolio I learned Apple's iDVD in order to display differently from most class presentations these projects as portable pieces of entertainment. You see, the limits of Garage Band and iMovie are that they're bound pieces of software to an operating system. They're great tools if you're working between multiple Apple computers and have an internet connection. But, what if a student made a movie and wanted to bring it to school to show? This is my inspiration for creating a DVD. Enjoy, and thank Ed 451 for all you "learned" me. (NB: a cropped version of the podcast sits below for your viewing pleasure)

I anticipate using this podcast in my Hebrew Scriptures course, having students research a particular prophet and, with their text written, begin composing the vocals of their podcast. Later, they can round it out with images, pictures, and sound effects. These videos would be posted to my class website for their general review before a final exam.




8.17.2008

India: What's that Smell?

The start of my trip to Mumbai is aptly described in Lonely Planets preface...
"Measure: one part Hollywood; six parts traffic; a bunch of rich power-moguls; stir in half a dozen colonial relics (use big ones); pour in six heaped cups of poverty; add a smattering of swish bars and restaurants (don't skimp on quality here for best results); equal parts of mayhem and order; as many ancient bazaars as you have lying around; a handful of Hinduism; a dash of Islam; fold in your mixture with equal parts India; throw it all in a blender on high (adding generous helpings of pollution to taste) and presto: Mumbai... slowly marches towards a brave new world. But not everyone made the guest list: more than half of the population lives in slums."

India is other-worldly not only because it's on the other side of the world but because it presents a reality I have never known in any of my travels through third-world and developing countries. Arriving in India, you stand to face a complete onslaught on your senses... and assault on every inch of your conscious mind, and there's little room to relax because there's 20 million people packed into an area the half the size of NYC (the 5 burroughs included). Imagine two and half times the population in a area half the size... clearly god is not a closterphobic. After walking through customs, I exited the airport looking for my pre-paid taxi only to find a whole row of teeny-tiny black tin boxes on wheels. They're relics of the 1940's and 50's with emissions that would make any generation blush... but this is a day-in-the-life for Indians. Permit me, but this is part of the perspectival shift that's so crucial for travelers to confront and grow from... that is, understanding the cultural differences as just that--different. It's not a matter of right/wrong, and the sooner one appreciates the difference--considering India has been doing this for the past 4500 years--the sooner one sees beauty in the apparent chaos.

I sloughed my backpack into the back seat, and rested on the back seat pretty sure that a spring my bust through the vleour seat liner or, more so, my feet would bust through the rusting floor. Trying to relax, the taxi was drenched in the smell of sandalwood insence, which the driver placed precariously in the dashboard air-vents. We rolled out of the airport grinding through first and second gears, passing security gaurds, autorickshaws, horse-drawn carts and the first a many cows I'd see sitting in the middle of roads. Welcome to India.

I was staying at a hostel at St. Xavier's College about 12 km deep into the heart of Mumbai. It took 2 hours at 7am to drive the 7 miles mostly along the crowded overpasses that seem like they're facing the same fate as the I-35 Bridge Collapse. These overpasses are usually divided into three lanes, but--although I'm sure the city-workers who painted the dividing lines appreciated the pay-check--they don't do a damn thing to keep traffic from merging happlessly in and out of empty spaces on the road. There could be 5 or possibly 6 lanes of traffic squeezed between the lanes and shoulders of the overpass; scootters and bikes move quickly through the bottle-necked congestion, and rickshaws with their narrow profile attempt to follow. Cars tend to be pretty helpless in the matter, and usually suffer the same fate as trucks and busses that slowly drag along through the miles of snail-paced speeds. Horns blowing at intervals, communicating and alerting other drivers of their presence or passing maneuvers, almost sound like birds calling for their mates in a densley wooded forest.

The incensce had long sinced burned to it's aromatic end, and at such a slow pace i had the opportunity to absorb some of the most complicated and foul smells that would rival the best Cabernet Savignons and sewer smells, respectively. Exiting the overpass and driving through busier city streets, the car passed through a melange of spices and curries but just as quickly passed into a distinct smell reminiscent of a public bathroom at a ballpark during the 7th inning stretch... for variety, let's imagine all the patrons had intestinal issues and, now, you get the idea. It's a smell that only exists in India, strangely, and it's so distinct and characteristic but just the same aversive and stomach-wrenching.

The driver pulled up to Chatrapatti-Shivaji Terminus (CST), which I knew to be Mumbai's central train station. Up to this point, I had no idea where I was on my less-than-precise Lonely Planet photocopied map... but this landmark was unmistakable. Still, I had to find my hostel at St. Xavier's College and so begins my first conversation and interaction with Indians. I walk up to a security gaurd asking for directions, and with confusion he quickly glances over his shoulder to a fellow gaurd who apparently was the only one to speak English... if that's what you call the few discernable words, "walk", "left side", and "7 minutes" spoken at million-miles-a-minute. His finger pantomime indicated I should follow the road back and around a turn-a-bout for several minutes. Proceeding along, I checked with a few others to make sure I was on the right track... and sure enough in 10 minutes time I was standing at the receptionist desk with students rushing by, late for class, explaining who I needed to see. "Is he expecting you?" I was thinking, "I sure as hell hope so." and said, "Yes". I was led to my hostel room and, after the 20 hour flight, and a 2 hour taxi ride I fell in and out of sleep for 18 hours ruing the point in time I'd have to step back into the madness and assault that Mumbai plays on the senses... it took everything out of me just to get to the hostel, and here I thought I was young enough and well-traveled enough to make it through such hardships... I've slept on train station platforms in Italy, passed out on public park lawns in Pamplona, and even showered at public bathroom sinks in eastern Europe... but I couldn't stand to think I'd have to deal with this mayhem for the next 15 days.

Although the thought seemed appealing to sit and sleep my remaining days in this concrete room, the provided bed roll and pillow were little better than the plywood platform they laid on. I had to get up and out of there, but not without a bit of centering meditation... finding peace amongst the cawing crows, workers hammering out tiles, and the humid sweat accumulating at the base of my back and in the creases of my joints behind my knees. I set out to walk to the Gateway of India to find if there were ferry boats running to Elephanta Island. Determined, I sped by early-morning pedestrians and found my way to the harbor. Touts approached me, the obvious-looking caucasian tourist, wondering if I needed a boat ride... there's the answer to my question. Now which boat gives the best deal? I found a ride and had the fortune of meeting a London traveler who had spent the past 2 months traveling through southern India making his way to Delhi to meet his girlfriend. Martyn and I spent a few hours at Elephanta Island, marvelling at the 4th c. rock-cut formations that rival the architectural feat of Egypt's pyramids. I was able to share a bit of knowledge on Shivite worship and mythology.

We headed back to the mainland where he had arranged for a taxi to drive us through the popular tourist spots of Mumbai, including: Chowpatty Beach, Mani Bhavan (Gandhi's residence), the Parsi neighborhood, which is also near "the Floating Gardens", and finally passing by Mahalaxmi Dobhi Ghat which is "the washing machine" of Mumbai. Ninety percent of the laundry service needed for Mumbai residents is done at this location and by these people slapping white shirts, towels, sheets and blankets clean of dirt and debris.

Bottle-neck traffic ensued, beggars walking by the car looking for handouts, people deficating and urinating in corners of alley-ways, curries wafting through the open windows of the taxi as we passed through the technological-heart and cultural-center of India: Mumbai.